|it takes under 30 minutes|
|it takes between 30 and 35 minutes|
|it takes between 35 and 40 minutes|
|it takes over 40 minutes|
I wish to assign probabilities to these four outcomes. Before we actually attach numbers to these outcomes, we should first ask: Are there any rules that probabilities must satisfy?
Yes, probabilities must satisfy three general rules:
How do we use these rules to assign probabilities in the above "drive to work" example? The first rule tells us that probabilities can't be negative, so it makes no sense to assign -1, say, to the outcome "it takes over 30 minutes". The second and third rules tell us that the probabilities that we assign to a collection of nonoverlapping outcomes must add to 1. Nonoverlapping outcomes means that they can't occur at the same time. For example, the outcomes "takes over 20 minutes" and "takes under 30 minutes" are overlapping since they both can happen (if, say, the trip takes 24 minutes). The outcomes "takes under 20 minutes" and "takes over 25 minutes" are nonoverlapping, since at most one of these events can happen at the same time.
With these rules in mind, here are three hypothetical assignments of probabilities, corresponding to four people, Max, Joe, Sue, and Mary.
|it takes under 30 minutes||.3||.2||.4||0|
|it takes between 30 and 35 minutes||-.1||.3||.4||.2|
|it takes between 35 and 40 minutes||.4||.4||.1||.8|
|it takes over 40 minutes||.4||.3||.1||0|
Who has made legitimate probability assignments in the above table? There are problems with the probabilities that Max and Joe have assigned. Joe can't give the outcome "it takes between 30 and 35 minutes" a negative probability, no matter how unlikely this outcome. Joe has made a mistake, since the sum of his probabilities for the four nonoverlapping outcomes is 1.2, which is not equal to 1.
Sue and Mary have give sets of legitimate probabilities, since they are all nonnegative and they sum to 1. But there differences between these two sets of probabilities, which reflect different opinions of these two people about the length of time to work. Sue is relatively optimistic about the time to work, since .8 of her probability is on the outcomes "under 30 minutes" and "between 30 and 35 minutes". In contrast, Mary believes that a trip under 30 minutes will never occur (it has a probability of 0) and it is very probable that it will take between 35 and 40 minutes.
Return to AN INTRODUCTION TO PROBABILITY